Much of her work came about as critical and dialectical. Perhaps the most important is that the nature of the competition between states in the international system has fundamentally changed. The use of hegemonic structural power in ways that are. Structural power and political science in the postcrisis era core. Susan strange worked both outside of, and in many instances in opposition to, what came to be the orthodox practice of largely usbased international political economy. By presenting a new concept of structural power, this paper will offer a way to include the structural level into the analysis of power in ir. Susan strange s eclecticism, then, is central to an understanding of her work. Trade was mentioned in states and markets but susan strange regarded it as a secondary structure. Susan strange the defective state the argument to be developed in this essay is based on three simple propositions. Susan strange and the future of global political economy. Susan stranges writings on international political economy unep. The nature of dynamic interaction between state power politic and market wealth economy in changing globalized world will led in iraq post conflict country that their parallel existence often create tensions and greater economic and social role for the state. Strange power of speechsusan eilenberg 1992 eilenbergs subject is the. Susan stranges writings on international political.
In this new great game of states, structural power decides outcomes both positive and negative much more than relational power does, and the united states structural power has, on balance, increased. Susan strange, academic international relations and the. Analyse theory of susan stranges structural power masters. On the other hand, not for the first time, she criti cizes robert gilpin. In states and markets susan strange identified a source of structural power called the knowledge structure. Only the first, however, is compatible with the current neorealist choicetheoretical mode of explanation. Susan strange s multidimensional theory of power strange s 1994a fundamental aim is to move beyond the relational theory of power manifest in realist approaches to ir, towards a structural theory of power. Within ir and ipe discussions, this was either mostly ignored or reflected in an empirically. Each of these schools of thought has articulated and defended a distinct view on the origins, stability, and consequences of international regimes. The original theory of structural power was made known by susan strange. In concerto this has served the countries very own. Susan strange s theory of structural power in the international political economy by christopher may susan strange has argued that structural power within the international political economy ipe has four dimensions.
Choose one of susan strange s four structures that support the international political economy, and explain its origins. After the second world war, with the accelerated development of economic globalization, the relations between countries is becoming closer, which challenges traditional theory of power that is centered on the states. Today, i would like to introduce you to the work of susan strange june 9, 1923 october 25, 1998, a british political scientist who pretty much created the discipline of international political economy and invented the concept of structural power 1987. With this theory as a background we perform three case studies to explore the relationship between actors and structures, in order to evaluate the view presented by. Historical structures, social forces, and the constraints on. Strange s key weakness is the failure to account for her knowledge structures regulative form relative to her security, production and financial structures. Susan strange 9 june 1923 25 october 1998 was a british scholar of international relations who was almost singlehandedly responsible for creating international political economy. Thus, using the dictionary definition of maderratic, unpredictable, irrational behaviour, damaging not only to sufferers but also to otherswe have, as she puts it mad money. The uscentred crisis is often seen as an event that signalled the decline of us financial power.
As a result, big business has developed a profound structural power position on the global. Structural power and international relations analysis econstor. Economic power is the form of power which is derived. Ward 1987, there are a number of structural conceptions of power.
Finance, information and power susan strange the poin ot f this article can be quickly made it is jus. In particular, it queries whether the concept of regime is really. The purpose of this article is to redefine the term structural power, which. Susan strange, based on her research, proposed new theory of power the structural power, and built up her international political economics system centered on the structural power. Choose one of susan stranges four structures that support. On the contrary dependency is an antique bed due for the junkyard stopford and strange 1991. By examining the importance of states needs and goods and the available outside. Susan strange 19231998 theoretical rigour, any important insight provided by any of the three. Susan strange s reputation as a political economist will rest, i think, on the longerterm relevance and practicality of her approach and analysis of ipe, on the viability of her attempted radical ontology, rather than on the brilliance, or otherwise, of any specific book, chapter or. Susan strange and the future edited by randall germain. Hence, scholars need to be careful in defining what constitutes a hegemonic state and how exactly power is exercised.
Susan strange the purpose of this relatively brief article is rather different from that of others in this volume. It combines the intellectual goal of openminded criticism and commitment to exploratory research with a genuine belief in pluralism. This edited volume addresses the 20072009 financial crisis as the occasion to engage critically with the corpus of susan stranges work, in order to consider. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on youtube. Relational power is the power of a to get b to do something that they would not otherwise do. Claire cutler 9 corporate power in a global economy 152 ronen palan 10 the political economy of global transformation. In this article, we explore susan stranges multidimensional and nonreductive international political economy ipe approach to structural power. Susan strange s theory of structural power in the international political economy. Here she provides the student and scholar with a new model synthesising politics and economics by means of a fourfaceted structural analysis of the effects of any kind of political. The diffusion of power in the world economy cambridge studies in international relations, 49, cambridge. In strange s framework, power, in other words, is not concentrated in and does not stem from only one source but can be found and derived from a number of structural domains. In states and markets susan strange identified a source of structural power.
Finally, discuss the benefits the structure provided to those who founded it, and to those who manage it today. In states and markets, susan strange identified a source of structural power called the knowledge structure. Certainly, as regards power, diana tussie makes the crucial point that by seeing power as structural and agental, and by virtue of its complex character, strange was in no way limited in her understanding of either the forms or locations of power. Pdf towards a new understanding of structural power. The usage of structural power actually entails three different meanings, namely indirect institutional power, nonintentional power, and impersonal power. In contrast to this actorcentered behavioural definition, structural power is the. Venhaus power shift to the east1 china goes global. Here she provides the student and scholar with a new model synthesising politics and economics by means of a fourfaceted structural analysis of the effects of any kind of political authority including states on markets, and. By presenting a new concept of structural power, this paper will offer a way to include the. Supplement to states and markets structure in the work of. The third stance is the stance of what susan strange 1987, 2015 called structural power, which consists of international power structures of military, production, finance and knowledge. For strange, the structural power of capital is not constant and, therefore, cannot be accommodated in the logic of liberal economics. Structural power, on the other hand, does exist in every individual structural domain.
Structural power, by contrast, was the power to shape and determine the structures of the global political economy the power to decide how things will be done, the. Susan strange has argued that structural power within the international political economy ipe has four dimensions. Pdf susan strange and the future of global political. I argue that structural power is a variable that merits more extensive and more explicit attention in latin american political economy and comparative politics more broadly. Susan strange and the future of global political economy power, control and transformation edited by randall germain onrup. Susan strange, academic international relations and the study. On the other hand scholars like gill and susan strange visualized that despite certain economic and policy setbacks the hegemonic dominance of the united states in international affairs is still intact mainly due to the structural power.
Susan strange, structural power was a capacity mainly inherent in a few large states above all the us to exercise influence over other state. Instead of asking what makes regimes and how they affect behavior, it seeks to raise more fundamental questions about the questions. The concept of structural power became popular with the writings of susan strange see lawton et al. Strange was a hardtoclassify thinker hard to classify. The viewpoint of structural power is the international political economy. Lukes, reinhard meyers, heikki patomaki, susan strange, ole waever, and the editor and two anonymous referees of international organization. Dec 18, 2016 while the concept of structural power rose to prominence through the works of susan strange cf. Susan strange was born on 9 june 1923 in langton matravers county dorset. Relational, structural and systemic forms of power.
Bringing susan strange back in again international. Susan strange the distinguished swedish economist, gunnar myrdal, once commented. The power to shape and determine the structures of the global political economy within which other states. The relational and structural power of the eu in competition. She went to the royal high school, bath, and to the university of caen in. Second, it tries to test strange s model for its explanatory power, by using it to construct historical narrative on the development. The two key ingredients of strange s approach to power were, first, the distinction between tangible resources and actor relationships as alternative sources of power. In contrast to this actorcentered behavioural definition, structural power. Jun 22, 2019 this structural power means rather more than the power to set the agenda of discussion or to design the international regimes of rules and customs that are supposed to govern international economic relations. Susan strange the purpose of this relatively brief article is rather different from that of. Over 25 years ago, susan strange urged ir scholars to include multinational corporations in their analysis.
The starting point is a theory presented by susan strange, focusing on globalization as a structural cause for change in the nature of diplomacy. Structural power, in short, confers the power to decide how things shall be done, the power to shape frameworks within which. Susan stranges theory of structural power in the international political economy. Susan stranges theory of structural power in the international. Traditional studies of world politics, which strange criticized as narrow and. Request pdf towards a new understanding of structural power. Contrary to dependency scholars, as she reads them2, strange thinks that the influence of. Structural power, on the other hand, is the power to shape and determine the structures of the global political economy within which other states, their. This chapter argues that the global financial crisis of 2008 presented a unique opportunity to revisit them and to reevaluate strange s core argument about the enduring structural power of the us in global finance. Strange defines structural power as the power to decide how things shall be done, the power to shape frameworks within which states relate to each other, relate to people, or relate to 5 corporate enterprises strange 1988a. Guzzini 20 had argued that of strange s work structural power was her most important conceptual contribution. What susan strange calls relational power is a conventional and perhaps still the most common understanding of power, which was defined by robert dahl 1 957.
Professor strange was well known for her unorthodox and stimulating views on the international political economy. Susan strange has developed the notion of relational power in contradistinction to structural power power actors source not from the possession of resources, but from their capacity to control the structures e. By examining the importance of states needs and goods and the available outside options oos. First it tries to work out the logical consequences of the notion that knowledge is a source of structural power. A state, for example, can exercise power control in any one, or more than one. Power, control and transformation randall germain, ed. Over 25 years ago, susan strange urged ir scholars to include. Finally, this essay claims that none of the structural power concepts is able to provide both a comprehensive and a coherent power analysis, either because it still omits particular power phenomena or because it overloads the concept of power. Structural power, on the other hand, is the power to shape and determine the structures of the global political economy within which other states, their political institutions, their economic. Assessing structural power in conjunction with its counter. In this article, we explore susan strange s multidimensional and nonreductive international political economy ipe approach to structural power. States in the international political economy retreat or. The distinction between relational power and structural power should be. An introduction to international political economy susan strange, formerly university of warwick.
1151 325 1502 1097 1264 204 816 1353 895 262 1399 712 1095 1481 819 526 1157 760 1111 603 657 932 519 829 508 1156 130 816 238 882 1145